English Rules

Months of Magical Reading

September 25, 2006

A few months ago, I started reading Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone to my son, Ben. When we finished, I thought that we could go back to smaller, more manageable books. But Ben was adamant: "Daddy, let's read the next one." So we did.

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

During scary parts, I would pause and ask Ben if he was scared and if he wanted me to stop or continue, to which he would usually reply, "I'm not scared. Well, maybe just a little scared. But keep reading, Dad. Keep reading!" So I kept reading. And reading. We just completed book 6, The Half-Blood Prince, a couple weeks ago.

The books were such a joy to read to him, even though at times I wasn't sure if Ben was old enough or mature enough to hear about what was going on in there. I did skip over little bits of the book, The Order of the Phoenix, because Harry's incessant whining became intolerable to me and all the characters' use of words such as "stupid" and "bloody hell" was not something I wanted to repeatedly inflict on my son. And I had to be especially careful during those times when Lucy would come into the room from time to time for her three-and-a-half-year-old dose of Harry and friends. All in all, though, the books were surprisingly suitable.

Ever since we started the series, Ben has, perhaps understandably, become obsessed with all things Harry Potter — listening to the books on CD, playing with Harry Potter action figures that his Auntie Tash got him from Good Will, watching the movie versions of the first four books. He even borrowed a costume from his older cousin and plans to go trick-or-treating as Harry Potter. (Lucy is still trying to decide between Hermione and a princess).

On a completely unrelated note, I've decided to start writing my own novel. I plan to call it Harvey Porter. In this totally original book, a young boy grows up with his mean neighbors after his parents die in a suspicious murder until one day he gets a letter at age 12 telling him that, as a superhero, he is invited to attend a special school for superheroes. Astonished by the news, he walks through the kitchen wall, soars thirty feet into the air and trains his x-ray vision on his next-door neighbors' house to see if the children who live there are playing some kind of practical joke on him. Seeing that they are safely ensconced in their beds, he floats back to earth, throws his few belongings into a duffle bag, and strikes out to Pigfarts school of superheroism and gallantry. And that is where the adventure begins.

Comments (7)

1Dad wrote:

I am struck by your description of what will be an important element of your relationship with your son years from now. How wonderful for him that you are interested in doing this with him, and for you that he is receptive to it.

As for your own novel, maybe Ben can be your editor.

Question: did you mean to say "inflict" or "inflect"?

Sep 26, 2006 ; 8:56 AM

2Mom/Cynthia wrote:

Oh for goodness' sake - I wondered the same thing about "inflect".

I think the reading time you offer your children is the Big Thing, Karl, as much as what you're reading. I also appreciate your on-the-spot editing of inappropriate language.

When you publish that novel, send me a copy - I'll love to read it. (Would you believe I haven't read a single Harry Potter yet? Couldn't relate. Maybe I should have a pep talk from Ben.)

Sep 26, 2006 ; 9:09 AM

3StealthKD wrote:

Having just watched the Veggie Tales knock-off of Lord of the Rings (title: Lord of the Beans), I think that your Harry Porter book will take off - and not just because the main character would be the namesake of a very fine beer (or do you mean to suggest that he is a tormented doorman?). One question: Who plays the "mean neighbors"? Just wondering.

Sep 26, 2006 ; 1:28 PM

4Diane wrote:

Okay, you know i think you are great, and that Ben is and will continue to be great, as will Lucy. This is regardless of what you read to your children, and whether you read to them everyday for two hours or once in a blue moon.

But really what I want to suggest here is that you consider diversifying the literary world by jazzing up the main character. I was so happy with J.K. when she gave Harry a multi-cultural girlfriend, instead of bland old Hermoine. (Okay, i like Hermoine, let's not get stuck on that.) (Although talk about whiny. . .) How about a nice Hebraic name like Hillel Posner, or why not a nice Spanish name like Haritz Posada? Let me know if you need any other helpful advice on your way to publishing stardom.

Sep 26, 2006 ; 1:30 PM

5Karl wrote:

Dad and Mom/Cynthia,
Oops! That was supposed to be "inflicted." Fixed now. Thanks for the catch.

The challenge now is to provide ample reading time for Lucy. With Sara's vocal problems and Ben's voracious appetite for books and my general distractedness, it has been hard to give Lucy her due.

StealthKD, (1) it's Harvey Porter. (2) Let's go with the doorman angle. (3) I haven't thought about casting the movie version yet, but any suggestions would be welcome.

Diane, as usual, you've made a very important point. How does Hazad Mohammed el'Potterdae sound? I do believe it's important in these days of terrorism and state-sponsored torture that we reach out to other cultures, especially our Muslim brothers and sisters, in a spirit of super-heroic reconciliation.

Sep 26, 2006 ; 1:53 PM

6Debbi wrote:

Cute idea... don't quit the day job just yet! Since your visit, I have been racked with guilt (sort of) about time spent reading. I have relented and agreed to read "The Places You'll Go.," on a school night. Do you know what I noticed? It is not just me who thinks it's too long, Dylan doesn't even pay attention and ends up picking up another book while I am reading! Which proves the point I made the other night; that book was meant for high school graduates! For now, I think we'll stick to "Lil Critter!" I can't wait to see the Halloween costumes!

Sep 26, 2006 ; 7:45 PM

7aunt ginny wrote:

Pigfarts? I think you're on to somethin' here, Karl! You could probably parody every fantasy book of the last 50 years if you put your mind to it! There's gold in them thar' digs!

You're not foolin' me, I know you're Peter Parker.

Oct 1, 2006 ; 8:38 PM

Post a Comment

(you may use HTML tags for style)

Notify me when others comment on this entry.


Comment Notification

I don't want to comment now, but please notify me when others comment on this entry:

Email:

Notify Me
Stop Notifying Me

In This Section

All Entries

Search

+ Advanced Search

Recently
in my life...

  • Geeking out at #tae2008 -- with Richard Worth and Jonathan Snook: Link and with John Resig: Link — Thu, Oct 2 at 4:09 pm
  • My wife watches history being made: Link — Thu, Oct 2 at 3:51 pm
  • Wow! What a bizarre letter McCain sent in response to Obama last February: Link This is a must-read, folks. Exposes pathology. — Thu, Oct 2 at 12:20 am

More of the same

Recent Comments

Me on Why the Button Fly?: My button flys wear out a lot…

Ken on The Candidate Who Shall Not ...: Nader is a no way... Obama is…

Daren D'Ippolito on The End of Four Friends: I just found out the sad news…

dean on The Candidate Who Shall Not ...: Well, I think this little conversation is…

Brian on Why the Button Fly?: Never found it a problem myself and…

Site Info

Elsewhere

My Bookshelf

Reading Now
  • Staggerford: A Novel
  • Four Seasons in Rome: On Twins, Insomnia, and the Biggest Funeral in the History of the World
  • unChristian: What a New Generation Really Thinks about Christianity... and Why It Matters
  • Light: Science and Magic: An Introduction to Photographic Lighting
Just Read
  • JavaScript: The Definitive Guide
  • The Art of Learning: A Journey in the Pursuit of Excellence
  • The Know-It-All: One Man's Humble Quest to Become the Smartest Person in the World
  • Jesus and Nonviolence: A Third Way (Facets)
On the Shelf
  • Design Patterns: Elements of Reusable Object-Oriented Software (Addison-Wesley Professional Computing Series)
  • Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid
  • Born Standing Up: A Comic's Life
  • The Elephant Vanishes: Stories
  • The Catcher in the Rye
  • The Tenacity of the Cockroach: Conversations with Entertainment's Most Enduring Outsiders

© Karl Swedberg

widescreen bonus!

+ Blogroll

Noteworthy Articles

Once Elected, Palin Hired Friends and Lashed Foes (New York Times)

Ms. Havemeister was one of at least five schoolmates Ms. Palin hired, often at salaries far exceeding their private sector wages.

Obama to Palin: 'Don't Mock the Constitution' | The Trail | washingtonpost.com

Sen. Barack Obama delivered an impassioned defense of the Constitution and the rights of terrorism suspects tonight, striking back at one of the biggest applause lines in Republican vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin's speech to the GOP convention...

Attacks, praise stretch truth at GOP convention - (Associated Press

Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin and her Republican supporters held back little Wednesday as they issued dismissive attacks on Barack Obama and flattering praise on her credentials to be vice president. In some cases, the reproach and the praise stretched the truth.

State of the Art - New Nikon Holds a Secret - NYTimes.com

If you saw it just sitting there, you?d never guess that the new Nikon D90 is a mind-blowing, game-changing camera...

Captcha is broken - now what? (The Guardian)

Websites use Captchas in an attempt to disrupt the spam and malware economy - but they are not working...

Hoping It's Biden (New York Times)

Barack Obama has decided upon a vice-presidential running mate. And while I don't know who it is as I write, for the good of the country, I hope he picked Joe Biden...

The Candidate We Still Don?t Know (New York Times)

Most Americans still don't know, as Marshall writes, that on the campaign trail "McCain frequently forgets key elements of policies, gets countries' names wrong, forgets things he?s said only hours or days before and is frequently just confused." ...

Is Jon Stewart the Most Trusted Man in America? (New York Times)

Mr. Stewart describes his job as "throwing spitballs" from the back of the room and points out that "The Daily Show" mandate is to entertain, not inform. Still, he and his writers have energetically tackled the big issues of the day...

10 Things to Scratch From Your Worry List (NYTimes.com)

I?ve rounded up a list of 10 things not to worry about on your vacation.

The Disadvantages of an Elite Education (The American Scholar)

Our best universities have forgotten that the reason they exist is to make minds, not careers...z

We're Not Laughing at You, or With You (NYTimes.com)

Let's talk about the bloody crossroads where satire goes searching for its target...

Turf War (The New Yorker)

Americans can?t live without their lawns--but how long can they live with them?

Graffiti artist Banksy unmasked (Daily Mail)

He is perhaps the most famous, or infamous, artist alive. To some a genius, to others a vandal. Always controversial, he inspires admiration and provokes outrage in equal measure...

Behind the Bush Bust - Op-Ed (New York Times)

Other politicians besides Mr. Bush share the blame for the mess we?re in ? but most of them are Republicans...

On Day Care, Google Makes a Rare Fumble (NYTimes.com)

Parents who had been paying $1,425 a month for infant care would see their costs rise to nearly $2,500 ? well above the market rate. For parents with toddlers and preschoolers, who were charged less, the price increases were equally eye-popping